# What’s the Difference Between Fiber Cement and Vinyl Siding?

- Link: https://mycoastalwindows.com/faq/whats-the-difference-between-fiber-cement-and-vinyl-siding/
- Published: 2026-04-30T13:21:58-04:00
- Author: dev@searchoutsidethebox.com

[Fiber cement and vinyl siding](https://mycoastalwindows.com/siding/) look similar—
but perform worlds apart. Coastal Windows & Exteriors is a woman-owned exterior 
remodeling company that has completed 7,000+ installations since 2011 across 730
+ towns in Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Maine, installing both fiber cement 
and vinyl siding built to hold up through cold-climate weather.

The gap in durability, fire behavior, and longevity is significant.

## **Fiber Cement vs. Vinyl: A Straight Comparison**

 * **Thickness:** James Hardie is 5 times thicker than vinyl — real impact resistance
   under pressure.
 * **Color Longevity:** Vinyl fades in 5 years. ColorPlus carries a 15-year warranty
   against fading and peeling.
 * **Cold Weather:** Vinyl cracks in winter. Fiber cement holds shape through freeze-
   thaw cycles.
 * **Fire Behavior:** Vinyl melts and releases toxic fumes. James Hardie has a Class
   A fire rating — slows flame spread. Not fireproof.
 * **ROI:** Fiber cement: 144%. Vinyl: 97%. Per the Cost vs Value report by Remodeling.

| Option | Pros | Cons | Avg. Cost | 
| James Hardie | Class A fire, 144% ROI, 30-yr warranty | Higher upfront cost | ~$20,678 | 
| Vinyl Siding | Lower upfront cost | Fades, cracks, toxic in fire | ~$17,590 |

### Which Should You Choose?

 * **Top Recommendation:** James Hardie for lasting beauty and long-term protection.
 * **Best for Budget:** Vinyl if upfront cost is the sole priority — knowing its
   limitations.
 * **Best for Historic Homes:** HardiePlank to honor 1920s Colonial character.

[Request a free siding estimate from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.](https://mycoastalwindows.com/promotions/)

[Browse our complete siding FAQ guide from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.](https://mycoastalwindows.com/resources/faqs/siding/)

[Explore our Siding Exterior Remodeling Home Improvement Help Center.](https://mycoastalwindows.com/free-homeowner-resources/siding/)

Still have questions about what’s the difference between fiber cement and vinyl 
siding? See the [areas we serve](https://mycoastalwindows.com/areas-we-serve/) and
talk to your local siding contractor.

Last Updated: July 2026

Sources:

 * Fiber cement siding returns 144% ROI in New England. JLC Online [Cost vs. Value 2025 – New England](https://www.jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/new-england/),
   JLC Online’s regional cost-versus-value analysis for fiber cement siding in the
   New England market. (2026)
 * Vinyl siding delivers a 97% return on investment at resale. JLC Online [Cost vs. Value 2025](https://www.jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/),
   JLC Online’s national cost-versus-value analysis for vinyl siding replacement.(
   2026)
 * The average cost of fiber cement siding in New England is $20,678. JLC Online
   [Cost vs. Value 2025 – New England](https://www.jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/new-england/),
   JLC Online’s regional pricing data for fiber cement siding installation in the
   New England market. (2026)
 * The average cost of vinyl siding in New England is $17,590. JLC Online [Cost vs. Value 2025 – New England](https://www.jlconline.com/cost-vs-value/2025/new-england/),
   JLC Online’s regional pricing data for vinyl siding installation in the New England
   market. (2026)
