⭐ 4.8 ★ | 880+ Google Reviews • BBB A+ Rated | Serving 545+ Towns in MA, NH & ME — Check Your Town »

Having trouble?

Stop Drafts Before Winter Hits: 50% Off Installation or 0% Financing Until 2027 + $250 Bonus When You Book Online!

Composite Siding vs Vinyl Siding: Which Is Right for Your New England Home?

See If We Serve Your Town & Instantly Schedule Your Free Estimate for Windows, Roofing, Siding & Doors »

Are you looking to select the perfect siding for your New England Home? When it comes to popular siding materials, many homeowners wonder about Composite Siding vs Vinyl Siding.

Both siding materials have their strong points–but vinyl siding is the clear winner in many categories. For New England homeowners, vinyl comes with unmatched durability, energy efficiency, and nearly zero maintenance requirements!

vinyl siding installation

Composite Siding vs Vinyl Siding: Energy Efficiency and Insulation Power

Can your siding actually lower your energy bills? With vinyl siding and its foam-back insulation, the answer is a resounding yes! Vinyl’s excellent insulation properties make it a top choice for energy-conscious homeowners.

Vinyl Siding Saves Energy Year-Round

  • Higher R-Value: Foam-back vinyl siding provides an R-value up to 19% higher than standard EPS foam, creating a thermal blanket for better indoor temperature control and energy savings.
  • Continuous Insulation: Foam-backed vinyl forms a seamless insulating layer that blocks heat loss through studs, preventing energy leaks.
  • Year-Round Energy Savings: With up to 25% of energy loss attributed to outdated siding, vinyl’s insulating power greatly reduces this impact, even in colder weather.

Composite Siding Allows More Heat Loss

  • Lower R-Value: Composite siding, even advanced options like Everlast Advanced Composite Siding, lacks the R-value that vinyl achieves with foam-back insulation.
  • Inconsistent Insulation: Composite typically doesn’t offer continuous insulation, allowing more potential for heat loss.
  • Limited Energy Efficiency: Without the same insulation power as vinyl, composite siding may lead to higher heating and cooling costs.

Composite vs Vinyl Siding–Which is Maintenance Free?

What’s better than a siding option that practically takes care of itself? Vinyl siding offers a worry-free, maintenance-free solution for homeowners looking to minimize upkeep.

Never Sand, Stain, or Paint Again with Vinyl Siding

  • Non-Porous Surface: Vinyl doesn’t rot, chip, peel, or fade, meaning it maintains its appearance through all weather conditions.
  • No Painting or Sanding Needed: Say goodbye to repainting or repairs—vinyl looks beautiful with nearly no maintenance necessary!
  • High Impact Resistance: Foam-back vinyl can withstand impacts up to 5x better than hollow-back siding, adding an extra layer of durability to your home.

Composite Requires More Care

  • More Frequent Upkeep: Composite siding may require occasional repainting or repairs to retain its look, especially as it weathers over time.
  • Potential for Rot: While some composites are resistant to moisture, they are generally more susceptible to deterioration than vinyl’s non-porous surface.
  • Lower Impact Resistance: Composite doesn’t hold up to impact as well as vinyl, making it more prone to dents or damage from external forces.

Say Yes to Vinyl’s Style Variety and Color Choices

Can vinyl siding bring your dream home to life? Yes, especially when you work with Coastal Windows & Exteriors!

blue vinyl siding style

Vinyl’s Versatile Style Options

  • Broad Color Range: From deep Espresso to Smoky Slate, vinyl offers a wide selection of fade-resistant colors.
  • Multiple Textures and Styles: Vinyl siding can mimic wood grain, come in smooth finishes, or be designed as board and batten, clapboard, Dutch lap, or cedar shake, giving homeowners the freedom to choose.
  • Prevent Color Fading with Chromatix™: Install vinyl siding with Chromatix–a specialized technology that enhances color vibrancy and UV resistance in siding materials, allowing them to remain vivid and fade-resistant over time. It’s designed to keep exterior colors looking fresh and bright, even under intense sunlight!


click to get your free estimate

Composite’s Style Can’t Compare to Vinyl

  • Limited Color Selection: Composite siding, including Everlast Composite Siding, has fewer color choices compared to vinyl’s broad palette.
  • Less Style Variety: Composite lacks the wide range of textures and styles offered by vinyl, meaning fewer customization options for your home’s appearance.
  • Color Fading: Composite siding colors may fade faster under sun exposure, leading to a need for repainting or touch-ups. There’s no need to worry when you install siding

Get the Best Return on Investment (ROI) and Warranty

Is vinyl siding a sound financial choice? Absolutely, especially for New England homeowners! Vinyl provides impressive long-term value and peace of mind with industry-leading warranties.

Vinyl’s Long-Term Value

  • High ROI in New England: Vinyl siding offers up to 118% return on investment, making it a smart choice for future resale value.
  • Comprehensive Warranty: With a lifetime warranty that covers both product and installation, vinyl provides exceptional coverage, giving homeowners added security.

Composite’s Drawbacks in Investment

  • Lower ROI: Composite siding generally doesn’t yield as high a return on investment, especially in markets like New England where vinyl is a popular choice.
  • Limited Warranty: Composite warranties vary, often with shorter or limited coverage, which may not provide the same peace of mind as vinyl’s lifetime warranty.
  • Higher Potential for Replacement Costs: With composite’s need for occasional repainting or repairs, the upkeep can reduce the value of your investment over time.

Composite Siding vs Vinyl Siding: New England Home Transformations

Looking to see how transformative vinyl siding can be? We’ve installed vinyl siding on countless New England homes! Take a look at some of the transformations below.

Get a Free Estimate on Vinyl Siding from Coastal Windows & Exteriors

Coastal Windows & Exteriors is the #1 woman-owned vinyl siding company in New England, dubbed by INC 5000. Trust us as your local siding contractor, offering top-quality craftsmanship and excellent warranties for your peace of mind. Call today for a fast, free, and friendly estimate!

Share:

Get Your Free Estimate

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Product Interest
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

By checking the button, you authorize Coastal Windows & Exteriors to email, SMS, or contact/call you at the phone number you provided using automated telephone technology including auto-dialers, pre-recorded messages, email messages, and text messages, regarding offers about their products and services, even if your phone is a mobile phone number or is currently listed on any state, federal or corporate DO Not Call Lists; and you are not required to give your consent here as a condition of service. Message and data rates may apply. You may revoke this consent at any time.

Blog Categories

SAVE 50%
OFF INSTALLATION

Huge savings on Windows, Siding, Roofing & Doors!

OR NO INTEREST, NO PAYMENTS UNTIL 2026