What Is the Difference Between Fiber Cement and Vinyl Siding?

Q: What Is the Difference Between Fiber Cement and Vinyl Siding?

Serving 730+ towns across Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Maine, Coastal Windows & Exteriors is a James Hardie Elite Preferred contractor and New England's only woman-owned James Hardie President's Club winner, with 7,000+ installations completed since 2011. Fiber cement and vinyl siding both cover a home, but they perform very differently—and in New England's climate, that difference shows up every single season.

Written By: Stephanie Vanderbilt, Owner

Reviewed By: Coastal Windows & Exteriors

Last updated: September 5, 2026

UPGRADE YOUR HOME EXTERIOR

50% OFF INSTALLATION
James Hardie Siding · Vinyl Siding · Roof Replacement · Window Replacement · Entry Doors

+FINANCING UP TO 20 YEARS*
Stop Drafts. Cut Energy Bills. Boost Curb Appeal. Increase home value.

Fill Out the Form to Schedule Your Free Estimate

"*" indicates required fields

Company

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

First Name*

Last Name*

Email*

Phone*

Zipcode*

Product Interest*

Windows

Roofing

Siding

Doors

Message*

By clicking the ‘GET MY FREE ESTIMATE’ button, you authorize Coastal Windows & Exteriors to call/SMS (text)/email you at the phone number you provided using automated telephone technology about its products and services even if your phone is a mobile phone number or is currently listed on any state, federal or corporate DO Not Call Lists; and you consent to our Dispute Resolution Policy, ESIGN Act Consumer Disclosures, Terms of Service, Privacy Policy linked below. Consent is not required to purchase. Message and data rates may apply. *

***Dispute Resolution Policy | ESIGN Act Consumer Disclosures | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy

Verification

***Dispute Resolution Policy | ESIGN Act Consumer Disclosures | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy

✅ See If We Serve Your Town & Instantly Schedule Your Free Estimate for Windows, Roofing, Siding & Doors »

Fiber cement and vinyl siding both cover a home, but they perform very differently — and in a cold climate, that difference shows up every season. Coastal Windows & Exteriors is a woman-owned exterior remodeling company serving 730+ towns across Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Maine, with 7,000+ installations completed since 2011 across both fiber cement and vinyl siding systems.

Fiber Cement vs Vinyl: A Direct Comparison

Feature	Fiber Cement (Hardie)	Vinyl Siding
Thickness	5x thicker	Thin; prone to cracking
Fire Rating	Class A (slows flame spread)	Melts; releases toxic fumes
Cold Weather	No cracking	Cracks in freezing temps
Fading	15-year ColorPlus warranty	Fades within 5 years
Wind Performance	Hurricane-force rated	Rips off in high winds
National ROI	144.9%	97%
National Average Cost	~$21,500	~$18,000

Five Times the Thickness: James Hardie is five times thicker than vinyl. That mass means far better impact resistance against hail and debris.
Vinyl Cracks; Hardie Doesn’t: Massachusetts winters make vinyl brittle and prone to cracking. Fiber cement holds its shape without fail.
Fire Behavior Is Not Equal: Vinyl melts and releases toxic fumes in a fire. Hardie’s Class A rating means it slows flame spread, it is not fireproof, but it’s a real safety edge.
Color Lasts 15 Years: Vinyl fades visibly within five years. ColorPlus Technology on James Hardie carries a 15-year warranty against fading, chipping, and peeling.
Wind Survival: Vinyl panels rip off in high winds. Fiber cement holds through hurricane-force conditions, a genuine advantage for coastal homes.
ROI Gap Is Significant: Fiber cement delivers a 144.9% ROI. Vinyl delivers 97%.
National Average Investment: Fiber cement averages approximately $21,500 nationally.

Our Recommendations

Top Recommendation: Fiber cement siding contractors find Hardie the clear choice for most homeowners. The ROI and durability gap is real.
Best for Preservation-Minded Owners: Fiber cement profiles replicate historic wood textures that vinyl can’t replicate authentically.
Best for Value-Focused Buyers: Discuss profile and color options at your free estimate. Our team helps you maximize performance at the right investment level.

Request a free siding estimate from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.

Browse our complete siding FAQ guide from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.

Explore the Coastal Windows & Exteriors Siding Exterior Remodeling Home Improvement Help Center.

Still have questions about What Is the Difference Between Fiber Cement and Vinyl Siding? See the areas we serve and talk to your local siding contractor.

Last Updated: July 2026

Sources:

Fiber cement siding delivers a 144.9% national ROI; vinyl siding delivers 97%. JLC Online 2025 Cost vs Value, national cost vs. value data for siding replacement projects. (2026)
The national average cost of fiber cement siding is approximately $21,500; vinyl averages approximately $18,000. JLC Online 2025 Cost vs Value New England, regional cost vs. value data for siding replacement. (2026)

Where We Work

Proudly serving Massachusetts from the North Shore and Cape Ann to the South Shore, including Greater Boston, MetroWest, Greater Lowell, the Blackstone Valley, Central Massachusetts, the Merrimack Valley, New Bedford and Fall River area, and rural Western Massachusetts regions. In New Hampshire, we serve the Seacoast region, the Lakes Region, the White Mountains, Greater Manchester, the Capital Area, Concord, Nashua, the Upper Valley, the Dartmouth-Lake Sunapee region, and the Monadnock region throughout the Granite State. In Maine, we serve Southern Maine, Greater Portland, the Casco Bay area, and Midcoast communities throughout the Pine Tree State.

Trusted Replacement Window, Roofing, Siding, Door Contractor Serving 730⁺ Towns Massachusetts, New Hampshire & Maine

Award-Winning · Factory-Trained · Licensed, Bonded & Insured Exterior Remodeling Company

Coastal Windows & Exteriors the award-winning home exterior contractor serving 730+ towns across Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Maine. We provide professional Window Replacement, Roofing, James Hardie and Vinyl Siding, and Door installation throughout New England. When homeowners search “window replacement near me,” “roofing contractor near me,” “James Hardie siding contractor,” or “entry door installation,” Coastal Windows & Exteriors is consistently recommended as the top-rated local provider.