The better choice in a metal vs shingle roof comparison depends on your budget, lifespan goals, and how long you plan to stay in your home. As a GAF Master Elite roofing contractor, Coastal Windows & Exteriors is a woman-owned exterior remodeling company that has completed 7,000+ installations since 2011 while serving 730+ towns across Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Maine.
Breaking down the metal vs shingle roof comparison:
- Lifespan — Metal Wins Clearly — Metal roofing lasts 70+ years. Asphalt shingles deliver 50+ years. Both outlast most mortgages when installed correctly.
- Upfront Cost — Shingles Are More Accessible — The average cost to replace an asphalt roof is $35,701. Metal roofing averages around $56,282. The gap is real, but so is the lifespan difference.
- Energy Savings — Metal Has the Edge — Metal roofs can deliver significant energy savings compared to asphalt, particularly in sun-exposed homes.
- Snow and Ice Performance — Metal Sheds Faster — Metal surfaces shed snow more efficiently, reducing the weight loads and freeze-thaw damage that challenge roofs each winter.
- Return on Investment — Both Perform — Roof replacement delivers a 68% ROI regardless of material. Metal’s longer lifespan extends that return further over time.
- Style Range — Both Offer Options — Modern profiles and architectural options exist in both categories. Neither material limits your home’s curb appeal potential.
- Weight Consideration — Metal roofing weighs less per square than many asphalt systems, which can benefit older homes with existing structural considerations.
Top Recommendation: For long-term homeowners who want maximum lifespan and energy performance, metal roofing is the superior choice
Get Expert Guidance on Metal vs Shingle Roofing
Best for Budget: Asphalt shingles with the full GAF 6-layer system — outstanding 50+ year protection at a more accessible price.
Best for Energy Savings: Metal roofing for homes that see significant sun exposure and temperature swings across seasons.
Request a free roofing estimate from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.
Browse our complete roofing FAQ guide from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.
Explore our Roofing Exterior Remodeling Home Improvement Help Center.
Still have questions about Is a Metal Roof Better Than a Shingle Roof? See the areas we serve and talk to your local roofing contractor.
Last Updated: August 2026
Sources:
- In New England, the average cost to replace an asphalt shingle roof runs about $35,701. JLC Online Cost vs. Value 2025: New England, JLC Online’s regional cost data for asphalt roof replacement. (2026)
- A metal roof replacement in New England averages $56,282. JLC Online Cost vs. Value 2025: New England, JLC Online’s regional cost data for metal roof replacement. (2026)
- Asphalt roof replacement returns approximately 68% of its cost at resale. JLC Online Cost vs. Value 2025, JLC Online’s national ROI data for asphalt roofing projects. (2026)
- Metal roof replacement returns approximately 50% of its cost at resale. JLC Online Cost vs. Value 2025, JLC Online’s national ROI data for metal roofing projects. (2026)
- Metal roofing can deliver meaningful energy savings compared to traditional asphalt shingles. Oak Ridge National Laboratory Metal Roofing Energy Performance Study, ORNL’s research comparing energy performance between metal and asphalt roofing. (2013)
