Neutral siding colors, particularly whites, soft grays, and warm taupes, consistently lead in resale performance. James Hardie’s ColorPlus palette covers every high-value shade homeowners could want.
Neutral siding colors, particularly whites, soft grays, and warm taupes, consistently lead in resale performance. James Hardie’s ColorPlus palette covers every high-value shade homeowners could want.
Colors That Move the Needle on Resale Value
- White Leads the Pack: According to Fixr’s home siding statistics report, 49% of design experts recommend white as the top color choice for resale. James Hardie’s Arctic White and Light Mist deliver that clean, timeless look.
- Neutral Tones Dominate Buyer Preferences: Roughly 65% of homeowners prefer neutral colors, whites, off-whites, grays, and light blues or browns. Hardie’s Pearl Gray, Cobblestone, and Monterey Taupe all fall squarely in this range.
- Soft Blue Is a Strong Performer: Boothbay Blue offers a soothing, coastal appeal that resonates well with buyers, a natural fit for New England character.
- Warm Earth Tones Age Well: Aged Pewter and Heathered Moss give homes a distinguished, organic feel that holds its appeal across buyer demographics and doesn’t date quickly.
- Two-Tone Combinations Add Depth: Pairing a neutral field color like Cobblestone or Pearl Gray with a crisp white trim creates visual contrast that makes a home stand out from the street.
- ROI of 144% in New England: Fiber cement siding delivers a 144% return on investment in New England per the Cost vs Value report by Remodeling, meaning your color choice sits on top of an already outstanding financial decision.
Our Recommendations
- Top Recommendation: Arctic White or Light Mist for maximum resale appeal, clean, classic, and universally admired by buyers.
- Best for Character Homes: Cobblestone or Monterey Taupe for Colonials and Cape Cods that want warmth without going bold.
- Best for Modern Styles: Pearl Gray paired with Deep Ocean accents for a contemporary look that photographs beautifully for listings.
Want to see these colors on your actual home before making a final call? We offer a free 3D Hover Design preview at your estimate, no pressure, no cost.
Request a free siding estimate from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.
Browse our complete siding FAQ guide from Coastal Windows & Exteriors.
Explore our Siding Exterior Remodeling Home Improvement Help Center.
Still have questions about Which Siding Colors Increase Home Resale Value Most? See the areas we serve and talk to your local siding contractor.
Last Updated: July 2026
Sources:
- Among design experts surveyed, 49% recommend white as the best siding color to help sell a home. Fixr Home Siding Statistics — Fixr’s survey data on homeowner siding color preferences and expert recommendations for resale appeal. (2025)
- Roughly 65% of homeowners currently prefer neutral siding colors such as white, off-white, gray, and light shades of blue and brown. Fixr Home Siding Statistics — Fixr’s survey data on homeowner siding color preferences and trends. (2025)
- Fiber cement siding delivers a 144% ROI in New England. JLC Online Cost vs. Value 2025 New England — Regional resale value and ROI data for fiber cement siding replacement projects across New England. (2026)
